Hi All,

I've got to select keepers for a 10-team, PPR, Return Yardage league. We keep players two rounds earlier than they were drafted the previous year. I've got to choose two out of a pretty crowded field. I've listed them below along with the 2011 round drafted and their 2011 points in this league:

LeSean McCoy (6): 302.3 points
Chris Johnson (7): 202.1 points
Darren Sproles (10): 322.6 points
Jimmy Graham (12): 273.2 points
Ryan Mathews (13): 212.8 points
Antonio Brown (16): 233.9 points

It seems like the safe thing to do would be to go with McCoy in the 4th and Graham in the 10th, but I'm tempted to skip McCoy and go for cheap upside with Sproles and Graham. Going with Sproles is risky, though, since he gets a lot of his value from return yardage, which is less reliable than offensive yardage. What are people's thoughts? Despite keepers, there tend to be plenty of great/elite players available in the first 3-4 rounds.

Relevant Settings:
QB/QB/RB/RB/WR/WR/TE/FLX(RB/WR)/FLX(WR/TE)/K/DEF
Pass Yds: 30yds/pt
Pass TDs: 4pts/TD
Rush/Pass Yds: 12yds/pt
Rush/Pass TDs: 6pts/TD
Receptions: 1pt/R
Punt/Kickoff Returns: 20yds/pt
Punt/Kickoff TDs: 4/pt

LeSean for sure since - if I'm reading your post correctly - you keep him in the 4th. I'd go Graham in a PPR league due to price/his level of play above others at his position. Aim for Sproles in the draft.