I recently made some moves to acquire Reggie and Rodgers. I know I can't afford to lose Johnson as my #1 reciever but AP seems to have a lot of upside. I have too many RBs on roster because until last weekend Issac Redman was my #2. Should I even consider making this trade and maybe packaging together some players for a #1 WR. I could even see trying to go after A.J. Greene with someone like Rogers. Thoughts on my roster and this trade?

I like the trade but you'd then need to do something about your WRs. You have Rodgers & RGIII on your team. That's overkill. I'd check in with the Calvin Johnson owner and see if they want RGIII. Then I'd be more inclined to accept AP for Andre.

Would you rather trade Rogers or RG3 for AJ Green? Is either giving too much?

I'd take AJ Green for RGIII. Depends on needs. You have Rodgers, you're not starting RGIII on a weekly basis. AJ Green would be started every week.