I'm in a keeper league. I won't say which side of the deal I'm on. Who would you rather have next year: Josh Willingham or Jair Jurrjens?

Maybe someone else would think the deal was lopsided, but I'd say it's pretty even (unless it's an auction league, in which case Jair's probably cheap). If I had to nitpick, I might say that next year Willingham is going to be 30. Meaning, he's likely reached his ceiling. Jair still doesn't have a full year under his belt, but he's basically jailbait and with a good minor league track record. I'd probably prefer him.

Usually I'd side with a hitter, but you basically took the words out of my mouth. Willingham is what? A 30 HR home run hitter in best case scenario. You can get that from a Jose Guillen-type. Jair could take another step forward next year and be a solid #2.