See as a Sox fan I place more value on Paps than a catcher. This is one reason I got rid of my Red Sox, I was overvaluing them.
I will try a fourth offer. I have had some success with recent trades just by offering a variety of moves or options. Cuts down on the back and forth crap only to find out they don't REALLY want to trade.
A: Give Rauch and Pudge; get Martin and an open spot on my roster
B: Give Pence, Pudge, Soria; get Martin, Lester, Hardy (I know, I know Lester is on the Sox)
C: Give Rauch and Bruce; get Hardy and Lester
D: Give Pap; get Martin
Let me know if you look at these offers and if I am overpaying or underpaying and I can snag them back off the table.
Also, I know Hardy may not play out all that great the rest of the year but right now I have Hairston and Tulo sitting on DL.
The other team wanted to try and move a pitcher for a closer but I am not big on his pitching staff. Sanchez and Lester grabbed my attention but I think (didn't research) Lester looks better.
I like A, B, D, C, in that order. I don't think A and B will be accepted, but you never know what others are thinking.