I think you did a great job buying in on Goldschmidt right now....and I'm fine with the return you got, but I do think the following is a mistaken rationale for any trade...
but I don't like Hanley
Your thoughts about Hanley should almost be irrelevant when it comes to the return you get for him (especially any negative thoughts).....you should always be looking to capitalize on others
thoughts on a player versus your own.
Plenty of people love Hanley.....and those are the things you want to capitalize on.