In a Standard 5x5, OBP league. In a vacuum, would you make that trade?

I trade Hanley for A-Gon. I know, "context". But based on rankings alone, it seems that they're pretty even.

I think they are pretty even. Agon has more upside IMO. I think he could return to his MVP type years from a few years ago. Hanley has the position eligibility thing but I just don't see him ever returning to his prime years.