I'm in a 12 team H2H league and have been offered Hamels for Aramis & James Shields and I'm kinda torn here. Hamels has been gimpy thus far but in his last two starts he looked lights out up until the line drive and the ankle sprain. I've got alot of mid range pitchers... Baker, Cueto, Kershaw, P. Hughes, Slowey, S. Richmond, G. Floyd, Wang & Shields and I have both Aramis & Zimmerman at 3rd. I like the idea of picking up an ace like Cole even though I think Shields is almost an ace. Any recommendations?
I am aware that many around here consider Cole to be a major injury risk this year but how come all the projections on this site still have him listed as one of the top starters?
I think you can get a different ace for that combo (CC, Peavy, Halladay) and if not, don't trade them.