League background - 12 teams, H2H scoring, 5 x 5. I currently sit in 1st place by 5 games.
C - Ellis (had Ramos but he just got hurt)
1B - Fielder
2B - Kipnis
SS - Desmond
3B - Freese
CI - Moustakas
MI - Espinosa
OF - Hamilton
OF - Pence
OF - Victorino
OF - Heyward
OF - Dejesus
UTIL - P. Alvarez
DL - Longoria, Jennings
SP - Gallardo, Darvish, Jimenez, Beachy, Norris, Dickey, Samardzija
RP - Motte, Betancourt, Janssen, Dolis, Downs
I'm currently top-2 in every hitting category, and top 2 in W, K's and Saves. However, my ERA and WHIP are awful, mainly due to Jimenez and a recently dropped Minor.
I got this offer: I give up Fielder, Heyward and Ubaldo I receive: Pujols, Brantley and Kershaw
Obviously a huge upgrade for my pitching, but do I even really need that in a H2H? Is it work buying low on Pujols and losing the steady production of Fielder + Heyward?
I need some help deciding here, I don't want to blow up a first place team hoping that Pujols rebounds.