Hello, I have been offered this trade, where I can choose ANY one of his pitchers for my P.Fielder. But I do not think 1-1 is ok, so he also proposed any combination of 2-2.

SP - CC Sabathia, J. Peavy, Z. Greinke, C.Lewis, CJ Wilson, J. Shields
RP - M. Adams, F. Rodney, B. Myers

I am thinking about giving him P. Fielder and I. Desmond(I have Tulowitzki and Andrus for SS) in exchange for Shields and Peavy.

What do you think? Can you think of any other combinations? What he wants is homeruns from infield players.

Thx

I wouldn't take Shields+Peavy straight up for Prince. He's an elite hitter in an amazing lineup. If I were going to do that, I'd want Greinke + Wilson probably.

Honestly, I'd be inclined to hold Prince and move Tulo if you can. If he didn't have that monster Sept last year, his 2011 would have been disappointing and he seems to be a little fragile. You have some decent SS replacements for him, but you don't say who would replace Prince, so I assume you don't have a top tier replacement.