I was actually leaning towards keeping both Marcum and Duke, at the expense of Carlos Gomez. The guy's hitting .253/.290/.344
You guys think he's going to provide more value than $5 Duke? He's a good prospect, but there's still a chance he doesn't start next year, twins go with Cuddyer/Span/Kubel/D.Young in the outfield.
I don't think it's a strong move to take a chance on two guys that have a propensity for wearing down/injuries respectively. Duchscherer hasn't gotten through a full season in two years w/out injury. Marcum wore down last year/did the same this year.
Gomez will have another season under his belt and he can steal 30 blind and has power. He could go 15/45 next year. And, if you're a reader of the site you know, I'm not even a Gomez fan. Anyway, that's my case for Gomez over one of those pitchers.