Our keeper rules are:
6x6 (OPS and Losses) Roto 10 team auction with LF/RF/CF/2 Util

Keep two players.
You can keep a guy for as many seasons as you'd like.
Keepers are draft value +10% rounded up. So a $10 keeper is $11 next season. Then he'd be $13 after that, and so on.

I need to keep two out of these choices:

Cespedes - $2
Kinsler - $7
Freese - $6
A Jones - $10
R Howard - $14
Rizzo - $13
MadBum - $17
J Zim - $9
Mike Minor - $5
Gio - $10


I'm leaning towards Cespedes and Kinsler, but I can see the case for Jones + Kinsler too. Thoughts?

I think I would go with your first thought, Kinsler and Cespedes.

Agreed on Cespedes and Kinsler.

Jones had a career year last year. Of course there is a chance he repeats it, but I think there is a far greater chance that he doesn't. Cespedes can only get better. I think he'll hit more HR than Jones and steal plenty more bases with a solid BA. Kinsler can easily go 25HR and 25SB. His batting average is always a question mark, but for a total of $9, you can't beat their combined production, especially when Jones by himself costs $10.