Hi Grey (love the site)
...and to anyone else who would like to lend an opinion

13 Team League (AL/NL mixed) 5X5 Roto
$260 Salary Cap
24 (9 positional, 8 pitchers, 7 bench) Roster Spots
My Roster
9 Positional Starters
C - Brian McCann $22
1B - Adam LaRoche $9
2B - Ian Kinsler $32
3B - Chase Headley $6
SS - Everth Cabrera $9
OF - Desmond Jennings $17
OF - Giancarlo Stanton $21
OF - Andrew McCutchen $30
Util - Justin Morneau $7
Bench: Jesus Montero ($12), Danny Espinosa ($6)

8 Starters
SP - R.A. Dickey - $5
SP - Yovani Gallardo - $30
SP - Tommy Hanson - $26
SP - Edwin Jackson - $6
SP - Ian Kennedy - $12
SP - Max Scherzer - $19
R- Carlos Marmol - $9
R - Chris Perez - $6

Bench: Danny Hultzen ($5), James McDonald ($9), Matt Moore ($14), Tyler Skaggs ($9), Drew Storen ($19)

I get to holdover 5 players with their salaries being applied to the $260 budget.
I am thinking I should keep the following players for next year:
Dickey, Scherzer, Moore, Headley, and Stanton

I'm wondering if I should instead be keeping McCutchen and Desmond Jennings instead of Headley and Moore.
Or should I be keeping someone else?
Thanks!

I think I would keep McCuthen over Scherzer. I think you could get him back at a similar price off you want him. Same goes for Moore but he is cheaper and I like him long term.