Hello Grey, Razzballers,

Please help here ... I'm new to keeper leagues.

I'm in a 14-team league that allows two keepers drafted last year only in the 5th round or later with a penalty of one round. Undrafted players cost a 12th round pick (barring anyone from the first four rounds removes most of the obvious keepers). I picked up Victor Martinez and Middlebrooks off waivers in the last couple of weeks as potential keepers. Here are the 6 players I see as potential keepers:

Victor Martinez (costs a 12th-round pick)
Middlebrooks (12th round)
Lucroy (19th round)
Shave Victorino (4th)
Michael Morse (4th)
Medlen (12th)

I wouldn't want to keep both Victorino and Morse, since if I have two players from the same round the second one costs one around higher, so in this case it'd be a 4th and a 3rd round pick. But I'm guess they aren't the best choices anyway. I can only pick two but please rank the top three bargains given the round they're available in.

Thanks everyone!

Medlen, Middlebrooks, V-Mart...

I would go Vmart and Medlen. I think Middlebrooks is next but I hate the sophomores. Bet he slumps next year and is a great deal the following.