Tim is a consistent fantasy starter , should I pick em up and if so for who ???

8 TEAM HEAD TO HEAD
BATTING STATS: RUNS, HITS, HR, RBI, SB, BB, K, AVG, OBP,SLG, XBH
PITCHING STATS: W, L, CG ,SHO, SV, ER, HR, BB,K, ERA, WHIP, QS

My Team looks like
C-M.Montero, 1B Miguel Cabrera, 2b D.Pedroia, 3B M.Young SS-Castro OF- Stanton , N.Cruz, J.Bruce UTL - Texiera, B.Butler, Victarino, E.Encarnacion BN B.Harper

Pitching: Weaver, Hamels, Bumgardner, Darvish, Beachy, Zimmerman, Wandy Rodriguez , Cahill, Smyly, Lilly

Relievers: League, Chris Perez

DL : Ryan Howard , Daniel Hudson, Brett Anderson

He looked pretty good at the game yesterday as I sat in right field getting sunburn on my knees (which is going to make thanking Jay Bruce for his monster week a bit more painful tonight) so I can see him Potentially being safer than Smiley or Lilly.

I'd like to disagree with my collegue, Trey. I'd take him over Cahill, not Smyly or Lilly. I have zero faith in Cahill. Plus Grey has been recommending to drop him lately, so I'd go with Cahill as the drop for Hudson.