As a 1st time fantasy baseball player, I have to decide on two keepers on this team I acquired. Yahoo head to head 6x6 league. We can keep 2 players for a max of 3 years. All of the following can be kept for 2 more years. I'm leaning toward Hamilton and Longoria, but what do I know. Any advice would be helpful.

My potential keepers are:
Hamilton
Longoria
Manny
Mauer
CC
Zambrano
Webb

Thanks for the help guys

Yup, I'd keep the same two. It's a pretty easy call. Only other possibility would be Longoria and CC, but keeping pitching is risky, so go with Hamilton.