I'm in a 10 team H2H, 6 Keeper league

Stat Categories: R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OBP, SLG, W, L, SV, K, ERA, WHIP

My current players I am considering are: Miguel Cabrera, Josh Hamilton, Johan Santana, Matt Kemp, Brandon Phillips, Brandon Webb, and Matt Holliday. I need to pick 6 out of these 7.

Locks: Miguel Cabrera, Josh Hamilton, Johan Santana.

Matt Kemp: He is young and his potential is through the roof. I think he is a must.
Brandon Webb: SOLID starter. I don't expect his value to increases, but his steady production in all pitching categories make him a keeper.
Phillips: For a second basemen he has great value. A lock for 20/20
Holliday: If he was still in colorado this would be an absolute no brainer... His steals, BA, RBI, Homer, and runs are going to decline, but is still projected to record possibly a 100/20/100 .300 season.

in summary: I am leaning towards keeping Miguel, J hamilton, Johan, Kemp, webb... I can't decide between Holliday and phillips.... OF position is deep, but second base is not...

I need help. The more I think about it the more stressed HAHA i get.

Thanks to anybody that responds

I'd throw back webb out of this bunch and i don't think it's close..

7 out of 13 cats are offensive so O is even more valuable than pitching compared to a normal 5x5(where offense is already > pitching)

I think 20 HR and a .300 avg for Holliday are low, and i'd think around 28 and .310 are more likely. Also don't forget maybe a dozen steals. He's got a lot of value.

Throw back Webb. You don't need Johan and him.

hmmm seems like it is a consensus so far to throw back Webb.

Thanks for the helpful advice! I'm still rather new to fantasy baseball so its a learning process for me.