10 team H2H
can keep two from rounds 1-6, two from 7-12, and two from 13 on...

Carlos Beltran 147/547 83 32 97 13 .269 round 13
*Allen Craig 144/469 76 22 92 2 .307 not drafted
*Billy Hamilton -/- - - - - - not drafted
*Ryan Howard 57/260 28 14 56 0 .219 round 13
*Andrew McCutchen 194/593 107 31 96 20 .327 round 3
Mike Napoli 80/352 53 24 56 1 .227 round 5
Jimmy Rollins 158/632 102 23 68 30 .250 round 6
Alfonso Soriano 147/561 68 32 108 6 .262 not drafted
B.J. Upton 141/573 79 28 78 31 .246 round 7
*Justin Upton 155/554 107 17 67 18 .280 round 1
Rickie Weeks 135/588 85 21 63 16 .230 round 10
Kevin Youkilis 103/438 72 19 60 0 .235 round 7

A.J. Burnett 202.1 16 0 180 3.51 1.24 not drafted
Scott Diamond 173.0 12 0 90 3.54 1.24 not drafted
*R.A. Dickey 233.2 20 0 230 2.73 1.05 not drafted
Ernesto Frieri 66.0 5 23 98 2.32 0.98 not drafted
*Cole Hamels 215.1 17 0 216 3.05 1.12 round 4
*Felix Hernandez 232.0 13 0 223 3.06 1.14 round 3
Casey Janssen 63.2 1 22 67 2.54 0.86 not drafted
Jordan Lyles 141.1 5 0 99 5.09 1.42 not drafted
*Max Scherzer 187.2 16 0 231 3.74 1.27 round 16
*Justin Verlander 238.1 17 0 239 2.64 1.06 round 2
Tom Wilhelmsen not drafted

The * means I'm considering keeping them. I want to start the season with Verlander and Hernandez but don't know if it's a good idea. The only guy I am certain about is Allen Craig and he will take one of my two last round keepers. Thanks in advance!!

Verlander
McCutchen
Upton
Weeks unless I missed a guy from the mid rounds
Scherzer
Craig although Dickey

Weeks is an interesting choice as I got him off waivers fairly late in the season last year but I didn't consider keeping him. Whats his deal? Do you think he will turn it back around this season? I was under the impression that with Prince gone, that lineup changed too much to accommodate him. He did come on towards the end of the year though. Upton I'm not too sure about. He was my first round pick last year, and while his numbers were solid, I think he will drop a round or two this season. I do like having the option to start the season with my pitching staff anchored by Verlander(2), Hernandez(3), and Dickey(not drafted) or possibly using Hernandez in a trade for a top offensive piece. So many choices! I'm bound to make the wrong ones...

I should clarify:

Rounds 1-6
Verlander
McCutchen
(Don't take two SP. It is tempting but you can find SP elsewhere. You can't find McCutchen's production easily)

Rounds 7-12
BJ Upton
Weeks
(I don't see anyone else but Youk in this category unless you can keep a guy that was undrafted or taken in later rounds. Let me know if I missed someone though).

Round 13+
Craig
Scherzer/Dickey
(One of these SP should be kept. Both are very solid but both still have some questions heading into the season. I think I would go with Scherzer because I don't like Dickey in the AL East.)

If you can trade of Felix for something else, that would be excellent although I wouldn't look to add another guy from the first 6 rounds and McCutchen and Verlander are a very good duo.

Looks good. I had McCutchen targeted all season as a keeper but I traded for Felix with about two months to go and he is a third round draft choice as well. I'll probably go with Cutch and Verlander there. As for the mid rounds I was thinking of leaving them open and just get my picks back for those mid rounds but I guess if Weeks comes back to form he would have to be kept. B.J. had a good season but im not sure how this year will play out for him. I'll probably lean Scherzer in the late rounds because I too don't care for Dickey going to the AL east and Scherzer should stack the K's again this year.

With that said where do you see Dickey going in a standard draft? Also thanks for the help!

Ok, so with J.U. going to ATL with big bro, does this change anything at the top for me? I'll be picking at least fifth in this coming draft. Do I let Justin back into the draft pool and hope to snag him again with my first pick? decisions decisions.

I think I would still let him go back into the draft. Could depend on who you think will be available with that pick but I think McCutchen is a better player and value. Same goes for Verlander. I would take my chances that you will be able to get a similar player as Upton with the first pick than the kind of player that will be there for you in round 2 or 3 if you let either of those go.

Ok cool. Thanks a bunch Mauddib I really appreciate your input!